Old-School Teaching Still Matters in the Age of AI

By Jessica Johnson

November 16, 2026 5 min read

As the 2026 fall semester nears its end, I, like many college professors across the country, am preparing students for their last week of classes after Thanksgiving. I don't have a final exam in my English composition courses, as students' research essays are their last major writing assignment. This semester has been very engaging for me in the classroom, as I have expanded on what I call my "old-school" teaching while still instructing students how to use the ever-evolving technology of artificial intelligence. AI has fueled the ongoing discussion of technology-use policies in higher education. At Ohio State University, we are in the second year of our university-wide AI Fluency initiative, which aims to "(equip) students with the ability to not only use AI tools, but to understand, question and innovate with them — no matter their major." When the initiative began in the fall of 2025, the incoming class of 2029 was the first wave of students to be "introduced to generative AI basics," and I have had an AI-use statement on my syllabi since 2024.

Numerous workshops have been designed for OSU faculty to implement AI in their teaching. Not all professors are required to use AI in their classes, and my primary focus has been to show students how to use it as a research tool. Before ChatGPT shook up academia in late 2022, I relied heavily on teaching students how to use our library research databases to find peer-reviewed articles and secondary sources. This was the core of my research instruction, as I encouraged students not to rely solely on Google to find sources, since questionable websites could always pop up. "You never have to worry about source validity when using the databases," I emphasized. Along with the research databases, I now show students how to use Microsoft Copilot to find sources and brainstorm ideas for essay organization.

I'm sure many of my colleagues have been thinking more about how to incorporate AI into their classrooms in a creative way to support student learning. Yet I also believe some of us still struggle to strike a delicate balance between AI and technology use and meaningful engagement. We want to avoid what Pennsylvania State University teaching professor Lisa Silvestri called "perfunctory" participation and "cheap and transactional" learning in a recent interview with Chronicle of Higher Education senior writer Beth McMurtrie. Many professors who teach required general education courses, as I do, have experienced students in a "perfunctory" mood. Many of my students are very forthright with me, although in a respectful way, when they tell me on the first assignment that they really do not like writing and just want to earn a passing grade in English and "get it over with." This is where I have had to dig deep and be inventive with my essay topics. Using a Gen Z theme has helped tremendously, but when it comes to AI, I simply asked my students whether they wanted to use it and how. I spent a full Zoom lecture explaining how to use Copilot for their research, showing them what questions to ask to generate detailed outlines and article suggestions. I specifically pointed out that when Copilot asked to create a thesis statement, they should treat it as an example but not copy it. After this in-depth review, I was surprised that most of my students told me they did not want to use Copilot. They preferred searching in the databases and looking for additional secondary sources on Google. I reminded them that while AI use was optional in my class, they would eventually take a course where a professor would require them to use AI learning tools.

It was clear that my students appreciated having options regarding AI, but I think they mostly valued the one-on-one time I spent with each of them to review their rough drafts. Although AI could provide an instant response, they could see that I am heavily invested in their academic success, as I read every line, corrected every grammatical error, and offered constructive feedback. This is my "old-school" approach, and it really resonated with my students. I see this as "pouring into them," similar to a saying I often hear in church, where pastors "pour into" their people so their God-given gifts can be edified to minister to and bless others. In this AI and digital age, educators must make the time to "pour into" their students. This teaching method will never be outdated, no matter how fast technology advances.

Dr. Jessica A. Johnson is a lecturer in the English department at Ohio State University's Lima campus. Email her at [email protected]. Follow her on X: @JjSmojc. To find out more about Jessica Johnson and read features by other Creators Syndicate writers and cartoonists, visit the Creators Syndicate website at www.creators.com.

Photo credit: Changbok Ko at Unsplash

Like it? Share it!

  • 0

From the Desk of Dr. J
About Jessica Johnson
Read More | RSS | Subscribe

YOU MAY ALSO LIKE...